PHI 1101 Chapter Notes - Chapter 5: Moral Relativism, Cultural Relativism, Alethic Modality

342 views8 pages

scarletcrow268

4 May 2016

School

Department

Course

Professor

For unlimited access to Textbook Notes, a Class+ subscription is required.

ngrosie3 and 39926 others unlocked

PHI 1101 Full Course Notes

Verified Note

22 documents

Document Summary

Relativism about truth is the biggest philosophical obstacle to critical thinking. Ex. if someone believes the earth is hallow, then it"s true for that for that person. If someone believes lying is good, then it"s true for that person. Both relativisms were advocated in athens by the sophists (group of greek philosophers who were socrates main opponents) Relativism about truth is sometimes called alethic relativism. Sophist- a group of greek philosophers who have gone down in history as socrates" main opponents. Skepticism: the claim that knowledge is impossible; another philosophical barrier to critical thinking. This idea was advocated by sophist and was opposed by socrates. A group of itinerant teachers called sophists ( wise men ) were travelling state to state offering instruction in everything from mathematics, science, and poetry to wrestling, mythology, religion, music and philosophy. Sophist"s specialty was teaching rhetoric the art of persuasive speech, which included speaking public speaking, debate, and grammar.

Related Questions

Brief and detail

If relativism is true, can you ever judge something as being morally wrong? Consider some really horrible actions, genocide, murder, slavery, torture or add your own. If you feel a relativist could say that these things are actually wrong, what gives them this ability? If they can't, why not?

Agree or disagree

Similarly to what I said in the first discussion on what morality means to us, I think everyone has their own set of moral principles and obligations. So I do think that relativism is true, to a point however. I used Adolf Hitler and the Nazi empire as an example in the first discussion so I will use that here. Hitler knew in his brain that what he was doing was good for his nation and arguably the world. Now, as a modern day society we can agree that was wrong. For him, it was good. In his own mind, he is right. But it is relative to the person. Generally speaking we all have similar notions of what is right and what is wrong. Most people would say that going out of your way to help someone else is a morally good principle. Selflessness in society is seen a good thing by the vast majority of people. When I say that relativism is good to a point, I mean that there is a general basis in society that deems actions as good or bad. And since most of us would all agree that hitlers actions were bad, then we say that he had bad moral principles, even though to him, they were good. It’s a little confusing even for me to put into words. Basically, if you actions are generally viewed in society as good, then you have good moral principles even if they vary from person to person. No one will have the exact same moral standards, but generally they all are very similar in society. So relativism is true until the point where the majority of society would deem your actions and wrong. I hope this makes sense.

Agree or disagree

If relativism is true, I don't think judging something as morally wrong is possible. Because the definition of ethical relativism is the moral standard only being correctly relative to each person/society, this means that the moral standard is created by you and/or the society you identify with and therefore eliminate the existence of an absolute moral principle. Since the moral standard is different for every individual, we cannot say that someone is morally wrong. If relativism is applied, that is. If a relativist were to say that they could judge someone as morally wrong, then that would contradict the main component of being a relativist. That every moral argument of yours is correct, therefore everyone else's is also correct. Quite problematic but that is my understanding on the matter

ell25

PHI 1101 Chapter Notes - Chapter 5: Moral Relativism, Cultural Relativism, Alethic Modality

PHI 1101 Full Course Notes

Document Summary

Get access

Related textbook solutions

Physics: Principles with Applications

Related Documents

PHI 1101 Study Guide - Midterm Guide: Critical Thinking, Cultural Relativism, Peer Pressure

PHI 1101 Midterm: Test 1 Review

PHI 1101 Study Guide - Final Guide: Critical Thinking, Bloodhound, Peer Pressure

Related Questions