FACC 400 Lecture Notes - Lecture 4: Rna Interference, Pharmaceutical Industry, Cornell Chronicle

43 views5 pages
FACC 400 - Engineering Professional Practice
Case Study 2: GMOs
Mélanie LaRoche-Boisvert (260565830)
Miaad Farhan Fadami (260750945)
Omar Bamashmos (260617216)
Ben Lewis (260582775)
Meagan Warren (260666272)
Tamim Ahmad Momtaz (260639460)
Question 1: What are GMOs and what are examples of food GMOs?
Genetically modified organisms (GMOs) refer to any organism whose genetic material has
been altered or modified using genetic engineering techniques. Gene modification is achieved
though the insertion, mutation or deletion of a gene in order to introduce a desired feature or
remove an undesirable one from an organism [1]. These techniques were used to produce the
first genetically modified mouse (1974) and plant (1983) [2]. Today, these techniques are mostly
used to produce medical or food products. Genetically modified foods have been created in order
to increase the quality of crops, such as increasing Vitamin A in yellow rice and preventing bruised
potatoes [3]. Genetic modifications have also been used to increase plant and crop resistance to
viruses and pests.
Question 2: What are the main arguments in favor of food GMOs?
People in favor of the use of GMOs claim that the technology could help solve the global
food security problem by increasing the quality and quantity of food produced [4]. GMOs can be
used to increase the food production of many essential foods, including rice, corn, potatoes, and
wheat, which are diet staples around the world.
Another argument in favor of GMOs is their use in medication. For example, insulin is
produced by bacteria, and the process could be made more efficient with GMO technology. The
technology is also used in the discovery and development of treatments for a variety of human
diseases, which could help save lives [5].
Question 3: What are the concerns in opposition to food GMOs?
Farmers and environmental groups are concerns at the environmental impact associated
to the use of GMOs, since it would encourage the development of ‘super’ weeds and insects
which are resistant to herbicides and pesticides [6].
Another chief concern is the identity preservation of non-GMO products, either by
preventing cross-pollination between GMO and non-GMO seeds, or by separating GMO and non-
GMO products at market [6]. The latter could be solved with labelling regulations, however these
are not present in all countries.
Finally, GMOs could pose a health risk as they can contain unknown allergens. Though
there is some evidence that humans responding to a certain allergen will respond in a similar
manner when it is transferred to another organism, there is a consensus within the scientific
community that GMOs do not pose a health risk [7] [8].
find more resources at oneclass.com
find more resources at oneclass.com
Unlock document

This preview shows pages 1-2 of the document.
Unlock all 5 pages and 3 million more documents.

Already have an account? Log in
Question 4: What are concerns related to Monsanto and not necessarily
GMOs?
Arguable the largest concern over Monsanto’s business practices stems from the
company’s ability to patent the GMOs it develops [9]. They have developed and patented several
GM crops to be resistant to Round-up, its trademark herbicide which allows farmers to kill weeds
chemically rather than mechanically and in turn allows farmers to plant crops more densely [9].
The modified crops they develop, aptly named “Round-up ready” are offered to customers at a
competitive advantage, and because they own the patents, they can choose to whom they are
sold, how they are allowed to be planted, and, controversially, whether or not farmers can retain
seed from their harvest to plant the following season. The latter forces farmers to buy new seeds
year after year, creating a significant disadvantage for those who cannot afford it, to the point of
edging them out of the market.
Monsanto also protects its patents aggressively and has been known to undertake
ruthless legal action against any infringements. To many, this behavior constitutes inappropriate
use of GMO technology. They have also been known to lobby and push for regulations allowing
GMOs to be planted, possible against the wishes of the general public and without sufficient
knowledge of the associated risks [9].
Question 5: Give a brief overview of the Bayer-Monsanto merger of 2016.
In 2016, the German chemical company Bayer merged with the U.S. seed giant Monsanto
to become on the biggest agricultural conglomerates in the world, though the deal is still waiting
on the approval of several antitrust agencies before closing [10] [11]. Bayer paid $128 per share
to complete a $66 billion deal, making it the biggest all-cash buyout in history [12]. In the United-
States, Bayer was largely known for its pharmaceuticals, and Monsanto is the world’s largest
genetically modified seeds supplier and dominates American farming [12]. The merger will result
is a significant expansion of Bayer’s reach in North America.
Question 6: How do you think this merger will affect the GMO and pharma
industries?
The merger would pivot Bayer’s operations to focus more towards its new crop-science
division, taking attention away from the pharmaceutical branch, therefore potentially reducing the
company’s impact in those markets [13].
The company’s stake in the crop-science market would increase to approximately one
quarter of the world’s seed and pesticide market. This causes a fear that the prices for these
products would unfairly increase, causing more strain for farmers whose lands are always getting
smaller while the Earth’s population and therefore food consumption is constantly increasing [14].
The merger could also cause problems for small GMO start-ups, who will now have more difficulty
making an impact on the industry since the market, which was already concentrated with a small
number of global players, will now be concentrated with behemoths [15].
find more resources at oneclass.com
find more resources at oneclass.com
Unlock document

This preview shows pages 1-2 of the document.
Unlock all 5 pages and 3 million more documents.

Already have an account? Log in

Document Summary

Genetically modified organisms (gmos) refer to any organism whose genetic material has been altered or modified using genetic engineering techniques. Gene modification is achieved though the insertion, mutation or deletion of a gene in order to introduce a desired feature or remove an undesirable one from an organism [1]. These techniques were used to produce the first genetically modified mouse (1974) and plant (1983) [2]. Today, these techniques are mostly used to produce medical or food products. Genetically modified foods have been created in order to increase the quality of crops, such as increasing vitamin a in yellow rice and preventing bruised potatoes [3]. Genetic modifications have also been used to increase plant and crop resistance to viruses and pests. People in favor of the use of gmos claim that the technology could help solve the global food security problem by increasing the quality and quantity of food produced [4].

Get access

Grade+
$40 USD/m
Billed monthly
Grade+
Homework Help
Study Guides
Textbook Solutions
Class Notes
Textbook Notes
Booster Class
10 Verified Answers
Class+
$30 USD/m
Billed monthly
Class+
Homework Help
Study Guides
Textbook Solutions
Class Notes
Textbook Notes
Booster Class
7 Verified Answers

Related Documents

Related Questions