LAW1113 Lecture Notes - Lecture 10: State Rail Authority, Forklift, Posttraumatic Stress Disorder
LAW1113&TORTS&-&CASE&SUMMARIES&AND&KEY&POINTS&
NEGLIGENCE&–&DUTY&OF&CARE&FOR&MENTAL&HARM&
&
CASES&
Case&
Details&
Wicks&v&State&Rail&Authority&of&NSW&
Ø Conditions:&
o ‘!"#$%&'&!())*+,#-,)./0(-1.+2,.34-*//.#+,
(4#+,0"*,3.+),#-,5**6.+2/,7+),0*+).+2,0#,
#$$7/.#+,67/0.+2,)*4-*//.#+,#-,6#//,#5,
$#34#/(-*,89:*+0/,$7+,.+:#6:*,7,/*-.*/,#5,
/"#$%/,8*;2;,$7/*,"*-*<<,
o =*.+2,%.66*)>,.+?(-*),#-,4(0,.+,4*-.6,)#,+#0,
+*$*//7-.6@,#$$(4@,7,0.3*,3*7/(-*),.+,
3.+(0*/,8*;2;,)*70">,.+?(-@,#-,1*.+2,4(0,.+,
4*-.6,07%*/,467$*,#:*-,7+,*A0*+)*),4*-.#)<,
o =*.+2,B4(0,.+,4*-.6&,3*7+0,1*.+2,B4(0,70,-./%&,
C".$",.+,0"./,$7/*,$#+0.+(*),(+0.6,07%*+,0#,7,
467$*,#5,/75*0@,8*;2;,(+0.6,47//*+5*-,07%*+,0#,
/75*0@,5-#3,*6*$0-.$,.+?(-@,7+),/"#$%.+2,
.+?(-@<,
o D**)+&0,6.+%,.+?(-@,0#,/"#$%,#5,4*-$*.:.+2,7,
/4*$.5.$,:.$0.3,
Ø Use:,E.0+*//,70,$-.3*,/$*+*,
Facts&
• F#6.$*3*+,8F<,700*+)*),/$*+*,#5,0-7.+,C-*$%,7/,
-*G(*/0*),1@,0"*,!070*,#5,D!E,
• H7+@,47//*+2*-/,C*-*,.+?(-*),7+),/#3*,C*-*,
%.66*),,
• I7+2*-,4-*/*+0,7/,C*66,,
• FJ!I,K,37?#-,)*4-*//.#+,).72+#/*),.+,F,
&
&
Gifford&v&Strang&Patrick&Stevedoring&
Ø Use:,L6#/*,-*670.#+/".4,0#,M,-*/(60.+2,.+,F&/,
3*+076,"7-3&
Ø Test:&E7/,0"*,-*670.#+/".4,$6#/*,7+),6#:.+2N&
Ø Conditions:&L6#/*+*//,7+),755*$0.#+,#5,7,
-*670.#+/".4>,-70"*-,0"7+,0"*,6*276,/070(/,#5,0"*,
-*670.#+/".4,./,-*6*:7+0,.+,)*0*-3.+.+2,7,I(0@,#5,
L7-*,8*;2;,/.16.+2/>,)*57$0#,/4#(/*>,/4#(/*;,
*+272*),$#(46*,7+),5-.*+)/<&
Facts&
• M,C7/,%.66*),70,C#-%,
• F,C7/,$".6)-*+,
• F,1-#(2"0,$67.3,727.+/0,I,8*346#@*-<,
• D*26.2*+$*,1@,I,6*),0#,570"*-,1*.+2,$-(/"*),1@,7,
5#-%6.50,70,C#-%,
• J**+72*),L".6)-*+,C*-*,$6#/*,0#,570"*-,
• O*7-+*),71#(0,C"70,"744*),7+),)*:*6#4*),
-*$#2+./716*,4/@$"#6#2.$76,.66+*//,
Annetts&v&Australian&Stations&Pty&Ltd&
Ø Use:,!76.*+0,P*70(-*/&
Ø Considerations:&
o Q//(340.#+,#5,R*/4#+/.1.6.0@&
o D#,S+)*0*-3.+70*,O.71.6.0@,
o M(6+*-716*,
o L#+0-#6,
o D#,$#+56.$0,#5,)(0.*/,
Facts&
• F>,47-*+0/,#5,TU,@*7-,#6),1#@,8M<>,C"#,C#-%*),70,
V7$%7-##,70,$7006*,57-3,EQ,
• ,I,/7.),C#(6),/(4*-:./*>,1(0,/*+0,M,0#,C#-%,76#+*,
• ,M,2#*/,3.//.+2>,"70,$#:*-*),.+,16##),5#(+),
• M&/,1#)@,.)*+0.5.*),1@,570"*-,7+),"7),47-*+0/,
/(55*-,4(-*,3*+076,"7-3,,
,
Considerations&
• Q//(340.#+,#5,R*/4#+/.1.6.0@',*:.)*+$*),1@,0"*,
7//(-7+$*/,2.:*+,1@,I,0#,F,8*;2;,7//(-7+$*,.0,4(0/,
3.+),70,-*/0<,
• D#,S+)*0*-3.+70*,O.71.6.0@',7/,0"*,7//(340.#+,#5,
-*/4#+/.1.6.0@,7+),4-*W*A./0.+2,-*670.#+/".4,
)*37-$70*),0#,C"#3,)(0@,#C*),8*;2;,#C*),0#,
47-*+0/<,
• M(6+*-716*',F,C*-*,:(6+*-716*,0#,0"*,-./%,#5,
"7-3,I,*A4#/*),0"*3,87+),0"*.-,/#+<,0#,
• L#+0-#6',I,$#+0-#66*),0"*,$.-$(3/07+$*/,2.:.+2,