ECC1000 Lecture Notes - Lecture 7: Traffic Congestion, Marginal Utility, Passive Smoking
●Taxi industry and ride sharing = different industries = there are substitutes for price
increases/decreases; if you include them as the same industry = less substitutes =
decrease price elasticity aka create a more inelastic industry
●Subsidy (opposite of a tax; buyer or seller gets paid by government for every
purchase) for solar panels - seller receives more than the buyer pays; producers
benefit the most as they get more additional surplus
●Foreign furniture manufacturer plans to join the market, before the entry it is known
that the price of furniture will fall after the entry.
○Shift of demand to left
●Suppose the government sets a price of $5 ($1 below the equilibrium) for the good,
we see this is an example of...
○Price ceiling, shortage of 20 units
●
Week 6 To do: Study for Mid-Sem Test during lecture (up to week 5 material),
Complete Aplia test by Sunday 23:30
Topic IV: Market Failure
Week 7 To do: Read Chap 10 and 11, Complete Aplia test by Sunday 23:30
Competitive Allocation and Efficient Allocation (Review)
●Competitive market allocation where demand = supply
○Demand = private marginal benefit (PMB): MB to the buyer
○Supply = private marginal cost (PMC): MC to the sellers
●Efficient allocation (max social welfare) where the social marginal benefit = social
marginal cost
○social marginal benefit: MB to the society as a whole NOT just the buyers
○social marginal cost: MC to society as a whole NOT just the sellers
Market Failure
●If the benefits ONLY go to the buyers then PMB = SMB
●And if costs only go to the sellers then PMC = SMC
●In this case, the competitive market allocation = efficient allocation: maximizes social
welfare
●Market failure = Instances in which markets do not allocate resources efficiently and
thus fail to maximise the size of the economic pie.
○Either SMB not = PMB
○OR SMC not = PMC
●Consumers only consider themselves NOT third parties (society, environment etc)
Types of market failure
1. Externalities: External to the transaction (not buyer/seller
○eg: include traffic congestion, pollution, renovation/making of new building
○Explanation of smokers = pollution to environment and second-hand smoke
inhalation = negative
2. Public goods: a commodity or service that is provided without profit to all members
of a society, either by the government or by a private individual or organization.
○Eg: include street lights, national defence, public facilities
○Non-rivalrous, non-excludious
3. Common resources (characterised by ill-defined property rights, as opposed to
public goods): examples include overfishing, global warming, forests (illegal
poaching)
○Rivalrous = if I did it no one else can
○Non-excludious = open to everyone
4. Monopoly: (this is covered later in the course)
5. Imperfect information: (not in course design)
○Eg: Financial crises -> People bought what they believed to be safe liquid
assets but they were not
6. Club Good
○Nonrivalrous and excludious good
○Eg: Country club
Externalities
●Externalities are costs or benefits of an activity that falls on a third party that is not
involved in the activity.
○Eg: in a market transaction it is a cost to someone other than the sellers or a
benefit to someone other than the buyers.
●Externalities may be positive (increase benefit or decrease cost) or negative (decrease
benefit or increase cost)
●Externalities may be on production (supply) or on consumption (demand)
Positive production externality
●Beekeeper helping pollination in nearby orchards
○Only wants own PMB = PMC to decide on number of beehives
○BUT pollination by bees decreased MC of apples
○SMC = PMC - benefit to third party. So, PMC > SMC
○No externality on consumption side so PMB = SMB
○Efficient allocation where:SMB = SMC
■BUT PMB = PMC, where PMB = SMB and PMC>SMC, therefore
SMB > SMC ie not an efficient allocation
○Basically beekeeper is already maximising profits BUT is producing below the
socially optimal number of beehives ie goods things are not produced enough!
○
●Education
●Government subsidies the exchange as it benefits society
Negative production externality
●Pollution
○Bob sold the orchard (not enough beehives) and purchased a factory that
produces paint, which also produces toxic waste as a by-product
○Without proper filtering, the toxic waste dumped in the river can cause
damage to the downstream fishery owned by Jay
○Bob will choose the production level that equates his private marginal cost and
marginal benefit: PMB = PMC
○However, SMC = Bob’s private marginal cost + the external cost to Jay
○So SMC > Bob’s PMC
○No externality on consumption side (Demand), so PMB = SMB
○Efficient allocation: SMB = SMC
■Bob has PMC = PMB
■BUT PMB = SMB and PMC < SMC so SMB < SMC ie inefficient
allocation
Document Summary
Taxi industry and ride sharing = different industries = there are substitutes for price increases/decreases; if you include them as the same industry = less substitutes = decrease price elasticity aka create a more inelastic industry. Subsidy (opposite of a tax; buyer or seller gets paid by government for every purchase) for solar panels - seller receives more than the buyer pays; producers benefit the most as they get more additional surplus. Foreign furniture manufacturer plans to join the market, before the entry it is known that the price of furniture will fall after the entry. Suppose the government sets a price of ( below the equilibrium) for the good, we see this is an example of Week (cid:549) to do: )tudy (cid:262)or mid-)e(cid:299) test duri(cid:300)(cid:263) lecture (cid:625)up to (cid:367)eek (cid:548) (cid:299)aterial(cid:626), Week (cid:550) to do: read chap (cid:544)(cid:543) a(cid:300)d (cid:544)(cid:544), co(cid:299)plete aplia test by )u(cid:300)day (cid:545)(cid:546):(cid:546)(cid:543) Competitive market allocation where demand = supply.